How a Redundancy Complaint Procedure Works

Ask a Question
How a Redundancy Complaint Procedure Works

The redundancy process is heavily regulated. Violations, or alleged violations, of these regulations frequently give rise to complaints. Ultimately these end up at an Employment Tribunal.

If you're uncertain whether the redundancy procedure has been handled correctly, you can get clarity by using our free Redundancy Rights Checker.

Trying to Resolve Issues With Your Employer Directly

Before making a complaint to an Employment Tribunal, you should attempt to resolve matters with your employer directly. During the redundancy process, the company should normally offer some kind of appeal procedure to which you can make a complaint if, for example, you think you have been wrongly selected for redundancy.

If the internal appeal procedure is not applicable because, for example, you have already left your former employer, you should write to your employer setting out the terms of your complaint and asking for redress. You should wait at least 28 days for your employer to respond. If no response is received, you can then proceed to take the matter to an Employment Tribunal. Failing to properly explore the other avenues of appeal and complaint which were open to you in this way can lead to your petition to the Employment Tribunal being dismissed or any amount you are ultimately awarded being reduced.

How to Complain To An Employment Tribunal

To complain to an Employment Tribunal, you use the ET1 form. It is downloadable as a PDF file from the Employment Tribunal website. You can either print it out, fill it in and post it to your local Employment Tribunal or submit it electronically. You can also get a paper copy from any Jobcentre. Once you have submitted the form, you should get an acknowledgement that it has been received and be given a case number.

Unfair Dismissal Checker

Unfair Dismissal Checker

Describe what happened and find out whether you might have a case for unfair dismissal. Get clear guidance on your options and time limits.

Try our Unfair Dismissal Checker free, here on this site →

Pre-Hearing Procedure

The Employment Tribunal will write to your employer, asking for a response to your complaint. If no response is received, the tribunal may issue a default judgement.

If a response is received, the dispute may be referred to the arbitration service ACAS. ACAS may attempt to facilitate an agreement between you and your employer. When this proves to be impossible, the matter will proceed towards a hearing.

If a hearing is going to take place, and there are still significant uncertainties about the case, the Employment Tribunal may request information from either party to the dispute. You can also ask for information from your employer if you think it is necessary to your case. A pre-hearing review of the case may also be held. You should be notified of this in writing and asked if you want to make written representations or attend in person.

Where your case requires witnesses and the witnesses are unwilling to attend, the Employment Tribunal can issue a Witness Order compelling them to come.

Employment Tribunal Hearing

You will be given at least two weeks’ notice of the hearing date. The hearing is not absolutely guaranteed to take place on this date because earlier cases may run longer than expected.

Employment Tribunal hearings are designed to be informal. The rules on procedure are far less strict than in conventional court rooms. Typically the hearing is presided over by a chairman and two lay members. The lay members are selected from pools of names suggested by trade unions and employers’ organisations. There will be one from each pool. Occasionally, a hearing will take place with only one lay member. This can only happen with your consent.

You do not need anyone to represent you at the hearing. However, you are entitled to be represented by whoever you like, whether a trade union representative, a lawyer, someone from the Citizens Advice Bureau or your cousin Pete.

During the hearing you will be allowed to say whatever you want and present or question any witnesses who are present. If you need advice on procedure, the tribunal staff will give it to you there and then.

Your situation may be slightly different. ask a question below ↓ and our editorial team will reply with our advice.

Employment Tribunal Verdict

After the hearing the panel will withdraw to consider their verdict then usually return a short time later to deliver it. The decision is reached by majority vote of the panel members. Reasons for the judgement will usually be given at the time.

If you do not accept the verdict, in some cases it is possible to lodge an appeal with the Employment Appeals Tribunal.

When the Employment Tribunal has found in your favour and awarded compensation to you, the amount should normally be paid to you directly by your employer within 42 days.

Redundancy Complaint Procedure – Conclusion

Most people find the idea of a legal hearing somewhat intimidating. But Employment Tribunals are deliberately designed to be accessible and fuss-free. If you have a valid complaint, therefore, don’t be deterred from pursuing it by fear of the formalities.

The Next Step

Unfair Dismissal Checker

Now that you have read through the advice above, you might want to put it into practice. Our Unfair Dismissal Checker lets you describe what happened and find out whether you might have a case for unfair dismissal. Get clear guidance on your options and time limits. Try it now →

Ask Redundancy Expert a Question
Cyclicalpedro 25/11/2020 at 7:16 pm
Being made redundant on Friday. Last consultation meeting was today (Wednesday). Only been shown a preliminary figure on a senior managers phone. Not had any figures in writing and won't until after I have left. Also, some of the questions I asked have gone unanswered. Should I have some form of written information before i leave?
Charles 29/07/2020 at 11:38 pm
Hi,

I've been told at risk after scored lowest in skill matrix among team of 3.

2 team leads carried out my scores. None is qualified in my profession. One we've never spoken or worked with each other.

Are the scores valid without any feedback from anyone, without 2nd review from either senor managers or HR?

Any ideas I can appeal to my manager or employer?

Thanks
Biker 25/07/2020 at 6:58 am
I have worked in the port industry for 34 Yrs and the company I work for now 17of those years Mid may 2020 I arrived at work to be told my job was at risk of redundancy and after the news told I could go home on that day .The following day I returned to continue my role meantime I was then told it was my day off of which it wasn’t and my days off were a few days away this was quickly changed to garden leave and a few days later to furlough . I was requested to attend a first consultation meeting and at that meeting was told my role would be absorbed within the company by people below me and above and the role would be covered that way .
I did ask about selection criteria pooling etc as being the senior with my own job title 75% of the role is similar at supervising level but was told no comparisons where made or scoring methods and it was restructuring as there was a downturn in business.
NJ 07/03/2019 at 11:03 am
I have been employed as an L&D Manager for almost 8 years looking after 2 sites, on 1st January my part of the business was merged with another meaning that there were 2 L&D managers (same job title and accountabilities) This was not addressed by my manager at the time and I was told business as usual pending a review of one of my sites viability to remain open. One of my sites is now set for closure and I have been put under consultation as half my role will no longer exist.

The other L&D Manager who in effect looks after the other sites that were merged with mine, is not under consultation, has less than 2 years service, was promoted under a DAS move that was not advertised 6 months ago. I was not part of the DAS selection as my managers for the last 3 years have not conducted any appraisals, mobility discussions etc so therefore not highlighted for a succession move. All my appraisals prior to the change of management were as a High performer which I have copies of. Does this make for an unfair dismissal claim, as the company did not follow their on processes?
Steve 26/09/2018 at 1:58 pm
I've been told that due to restructuring in the organization my role is at risk of redundancy. But I know that a Director recently moved from India to the US to a new role and employed someone who does the same thing as me as is based in India.
His role title is General Manager which is different to mine since appointment he's been learning from me and trying to asking for detailed information about what and how I do what I do so he can make sure others in India are following the process (which is what I was doing).
Am I right in assuming, that if my role is at risk of redundancy, his role should be too; and that at the very least this should be acknowledge during consulation?
RedundancyExpert Editor 23/06/2017 at 11:27 am
I think in this case you may wish to give ACAS a call for some direct advice.
Flower 22/06/2017 at 2:19 pm
I have been given notice of redundancy and given the opportunity to write a proposal to amend the suggested new structure. Whilst doing this I remembered that my job description does not match my current role. I was originally appointed to a temporary post which became permanent the job description that was given to me had my job title but the job description never matched my given responsibilities, even though this was repeatedly noted during supervision it was never changed to reflect my role.

Now looking again at my job description it describes a new post on the restructure, does that mean that legally I cannot be made redundant? I have been told my a colleague that I may have a case for unfair dismissal but I'm not sure can you help please?
free 07/06/2017 at 2:16 pm
Hi
I was advised last Thursday that my job was at risk (along with 11 others), yesterday I went to a consultation meeting to discuss redundancy etc. I was advised that no one would be doing my role in my absence and that they were restructuring the company and that the role would be shared by project managers. Today I have learnt that they have employed a freelancer to cover my role...so this means what they advised me yesterday was a lie, do I have any come back on this? Any advice would be gratefully received.
Many thanks.
Fred 22/03/2017 at 1:11 pm
Last week at the end of a lunchtime team meeting we were informed that some jobs were being put at risk of redundancy in my sub team of about 15 people. We were all told in a very off hand way that those impacted would be contacted by the "end of the day " (whether this was the end of the working day or by midnight was not made clear )

By choosing this approach and :
- not informing the small handful of people actually impacted before the meeting
- not setting a definite end time by which all those impacted would be informed
- not sending an email to the sub team confirming that all those impacted had now been informed

did the employer contravene the Health And Safety at Work Act which requires that it should always seek to minimise workplace stress ?
RedundancyExpert Editor 17/10/2016 at 10:25 am
Unfortunately, we are unable to answer your question as we are a UK-based site and have knowledge only of UK-based redundancy laws.
Wagait 16/10/2016 at 5:42 am
My son was made redundant after 14 years of service as sole site supervisor in charge of 33 workers. He was given no notice of his redundancy, and had to leave the premises immediately. The companies excuse for his redundancy was they were moving to another premises nearby (at this stage they have not moved to these new premises) and his position will be replaced by a manager from another premise (yard).
Is this allowable that he can be made redundant when his position is still there, and be replaced by another employee from the same company who has no skills for this position.
Sambuka 01/09/2016 at 4:26 pm
The company I have worked at for the past 9 has or we were told we were going bust Thursday just gone. We never had any prior notice to this we were also told we would not get our wages for the mo th we had worked. I have just found out today the the company is still trading. Hence to say angry and confused not sure if we have any rights in this matter. The company employed less than 20 people. Any advice would be great.
Kjbar 31/08/2016 at 12:33 am
Hi the company I worked for ceased trading on 26/11/15. I worked for them 8 years. They gave me no notice of redundancy. The companies Insolvancy practitioners sent me the necessary information and case reference number to apply online for statutory redundancy pay. My application was accepted and I was awaiting confirmation payment, however, I was then told that the company had not actually become insolvant. I have spoken to the Insolvancy practioners many times and they keep telling me that they are waiting for important information from the company before they can proceed with the Insolvancy. Now A meeting of creditors has now been set for the 13th September, can I apply again for statutory redundancy ? I only managed to get a job in July and have been getting more and more in debt because I had only job seekers allowance to live off. When the statuary redundancy was refused I was advised by the Insolvancy service to try employment tribuneral but I didn't not have the money to go down this route. I have now been invited to vote at the meeting as a creditor but this is optional if I do not vote can I still apply for statuary redundancy from the NI employment fund?
Thank you
Toffees71 20/07/2016 at 11:11 am
Hi i have been made redundant today after my notice period had finished and expected my redundancy payment to be made.however my employer has now said no funds are available to make the payment as they have applied for a government repayment loan and it has not come through yet and therefore i have no idea when i can expect payment. .where do i stand with this
Thanks
coco 02/06/2016 at 5:57 pm
My son had a meeting at work on 18/5/2016 where it was discussed that if funding was not secured, he may be made redundant. Yesterday, he was handed a letter to say he was redundant due to the fact that his skill set was no longer required in the work place. However, his colleague (boss' nephew) does exactly the same job and has been kept on. Surely if they were to keep one on they should have been reinterviewed for the post! Where does he stand? He's twenty one and been there for one year as an apprentice and two years as a trainer.
RedundancyExpert Editor 17/05/2016 at 11:50 am
I am sorry to hear this. I can only suggest you look at your contract to see what it specifies about redundancy. Also, if you think you may be being singled out and you are the only one in your company who is being made redundant, then you may wish to give ACAS a call to see whether your company is working within employment guidelines. While there are no set rules to follow if there are fewer than 20 redundancies, as an employee you should be fully consulted because if your employer is making you redundant unfairly you may be able to take the matter further.
Tandy 16/05/2016 at 1:54 pm
I received a phone call from my boss on 03/05/16 at 6pm (out of working hours) stating that I should look for an important letter on my work desk. I was in such a shock when I opened the letter, it stated that my boss will be conducting a formal meeting on Friday, 6 May 2016 at 3.30 and my boss will be accompanied by my work colleague who will act as a witness.

The letter stated that the meeting was in respect of the fact that organisation no longer requires the role of Administration and Finance Officer in its structure going forward and as I have less than 2 years service in total the organisation is not obliged to consult me in respect of a redundancy situation. The letter also stated that one of the possible outcomes of the formal meeting could be the termination of my employment.

I have been working for this organisation for 23 months and I will be 2 years on 15 June 2016. There was no consultation about my role no longer needed in the organisation. I have just come back from 2 weeks sick leave due to miscarriage happened on 22/04/16 and my employer was aware of my situation until after 2 weeks returned back to work. I receive a shocking letter left on my work desk. Since of the shock of redundancy, it has broken me mentally, physically and emotionally. everyday I suffer from panick attacks.

Could you please advise me on this matter.
RedundancyExpert Editor 11/05/2016 at 10:25 am
Your employer should use a fair and objective way of selecting you for redundancy and you can only claim for unfair dismissal if you feel you have been unfairly dismissed, see gov.uk article here. If you wish to pursue the matter after appeal, please see CAB whichI hope this helps.
ricky 10/05/2016 at 7:30 am
Hi I've been selected for redundancy after 29 years service. My appeal is due Friday 13th,only found out yesterday, if I don't appeal can I still claim for unfair dismissal?
Thanks in advance
RedundancyExpert Editor 23/02/2016 at 11:38 am
There are short, very strict time limits for making a claim to an employment tribunal. In most cases, you have three months less one day from the date of dismissal, but time limits can be different for some situations. For more advice, please see the CAB link here which will advise further.
Show All 30 Questions

Ask Redundancy Expert a question

Ask our editorial team a question and we will reply with our advice. Tell us as much about your situation as you can: the more detail you give, the more useful our answer can be.

You do not need to use your real name. Please do not include your full address, phone number, email address, or the names of other people. We may edit or remove identifying details for privacy and legal reasons.

Comments are moderated before publication.

Try our free Unfair Dismissal Checker Check My Case